0 0
Reuben Sandwich Our Way

Share it on your social network:

Or you can just copy and share this url

Ingredients

Adjust Servings:
1/3 cup mayonnaise (best foods or hellmann's or vegenaise)
1/4 cup catsup
1/2 teaspoon dill relish
1/2 teaspoon sweet pickle relish
1/4 - 1/2 teaspoon dried onion flakes, to taste
1/8 teaspoon garlic powder
1/4 teaspoon lemon juice (we use both, to taste, the balsamic really adds nice flavor) or 1/4 teaspoon balsamic vinegar (we use both, to taste, the balsamic really adds nice flavor)
black pepper, to taste
2 slices dark rye bread (caraway or not, it's up to you, but we prefer it without)
3 teaspoons butter

Nutritional information

870.6
Calories
471 g
Calories From Fat
52.4 g
Total Fat
18.6 g
Saturated Fat
127.3 mg
Cholesterol
3100.8 mg
Sodium
70 g
Carbs
5.4 g
Dietary Fiber
23.1 g
Sugars
33.4 g
Protein
307 g
Serving Size

Bookmark this recipe

You need to login or register to bookmark/favorite this content.

Reuben Sandwich Our Way

Features:
    Cuisine:

    This is great... loved the dressing. I'll definitely make this again. A Reuben never appealed to me until my husband had a friend that said how good they are... now we are Reuben lovers! It'a a versatile recipe... the sauce is enough for several sandwiches, so just get the amount of bread (we use marble rye), corned beef (or pastrami), and cheese you need to feed as many people as you want. I double the sauce recipe and we keep it in the fridge for more sandwiches and salads. Thanks for a great recipe... and my kids love the dressing, so we'll also use it for salad dressing!

    • 35 min
    • Serves 1
    • Easy

    Ingredients

    Directions

    Share

    Reuben Sandwich Our Way,This is how we make our Reuben sandwiches at our house. They’re hearty, messy, usually require the aid of a knife and fork, and are absolutely delicious! We think it’s because we make our own dressing… you can call it Thousand Island or French, whathaveyou. All we know is that we gladly lick it off our fingers when it dribbles. 🙂 It’s also a Pantry Challenge recipe, made with items we already had at home.,This is great… loved the dressing. I’ll definitely make this again. A Reuben never appealed to me until my husband had a friend that said how good they are… now we are Reuben lovers! It’a a versatile recipe… the sauce is enough for several sandwiches, so just get the amount of bread (we use marble rye), corned beef (or pastrami), and cheese you need to feed as many people as you want. I double the sauce recipe and we keep it in the fridge for more sandwiches and salads. Thanks for a great recipe… and my kids love the dressing, so we’ll also use it for salad dressing!


    Discover ground-breaking new supplements!    SHOP & SAVE


     

    Steps

    1
    Done

    In a Small Bowl, Make the Dressing: Combine the Mayonnaise, Catsup, Relishes, Onion, Garlic, Lemon Juice, and Black Pepper to Taste; Set Aside.

    2
    Done

    Spread Butter on One Side of Each Slice of Bread.

    3
    Done

    Heat a Large Non-Stick Pan Over Medium Heat and Place One Slice of Bread, Butter-Side Down, in the Pan.

    4
    Done

    Assemble the Sandwich: on Top of the Bread, Place the Sliced Pastrami; Top Meat With a Couple of Tablespoons of the Dressing; Then Spread the Sauerkraut Over, Add Some More Dressing, Top With the Cheese, Then Place the Other Slice of Bread- Buttered Side Up- on Top (this Arrangement Helps Keep the Dressing from Soaking the Bread Too Much).

    5
    Done

    Cover the Grilling Sandwich With a Lid (a Reverware Saucepan Lid Works Well For This) and Let Grill For 2 to 3 Minutes, Checking to Make Sure That the Bread Does not Burn- the Idea Is to Heat the Air Underneath the Lid and Melt the Cheese Easier as You're Also Browning the Bread.

    6
    Done

    Carefully Turn the Sandwich, Re-Cover, and Grill Other Side. (i Say "carefully" Because, Depending on How Much of the Fillings You Put in, This Step Can Get a Little Messy -- ).

    7
    Done

    Cut the Completed Grilled Sandwich in Two and Serve With the Extra Dressing For Dipping, Along With a Dill Pickle and Potato Chips or Potato Salad.

    Avatar Of Owen Silva

    Owen Silva

    BBQ maestro specializing in tender and juicy smoked meats with a signature sauce.

    Recipe Reviews

    There are no reviews for this recipe yet, use a form below to write your review
    Chocolate Chip Raspberry Pancakes
    previous
    Chocolate Chip Raspberry Pancakes
    Rich White Dinner Rolls Bread Machine
    next
    Rich White Dinner Rolls Bread Machine
    Chocolate Chip Raspberry Pancakes
    previous
    Chocolate Chip Raspberry Pancakes
    Rich White Dinner Rolls Bread Machine
    next
    Rich White Dinner Rolls Bread Machine

    Add Your Comment

    sixteen − 12 =